Steel toe shoes are a great protector for workers.
They save your foot from any small to heavy impact. It is even mandatory for workers in many states.
But some people have some fear about steel toe shoes. Here comes the question ‘Can steel toe shoes cut your toes off?’
Well, steel toe boots are designed to protect your toes from heavy impact. They are not there to cut your toes off. Some steel toe shoes might get crushed due to too heavy impact, which can damage your toes.
But quality shoes come with quality steel that can handle the impact. Though high impact will certainly crush the shoes, it can result in broken bones and severe damage. But chances are extremely low that it will cut off your toes.
Can Steel Toe Shoes Cut Your Toes Off?
Table of Contents
So, can steel toe boots cut your toes off?
This is completely a myth about steel-toe shoes. This myth started to grow in 2002 in Australia when a worker lost his 3rd toe in an accident. He was wearing the steel toe shoes, and a few steel pipes fell into his shoes. The myth grows after the incident.
But the truth is completely opposite. The purpose of steel toe boots is to ensure safety against the high impact on the toe. The steel inside the shoes is durable enough to handle the impact.
It prevents injuries from puncture, sleeping, or even cuts. You can even use it to break objects with a powerful kick. There is no such record that steel toe shoes cut off anyone’s toes.
Steel toe shoes can handle up to 6000lbs weight compared to traditional work shoes that can handle 1200lbs only. You can handle some common impacts such as falling some heavy items in the workplace, getting hit by something, or kicking some hard items.
But the shoes cannot take an infinite weight limit. If the impact is too high than the handling ability of the shoes, it may get crushed.
You will experience some broken bones. The crushed steel can also damage your toes badly. This scenario would be a lot worse than this without the steel-toe shoes.
But there is little to no chance that it will cut off your toes. If you know the purpose of steel toe boots, you will find the answer.
The Proof That Steel Toe Shoes Do Not Cut Off Your Toes
Some experiments have been done to understand whether steel toe shoes cut off the toes or not. Adam and Jamie from Mythbusters TV series conducted a few experiments to see whether the myth was right.
Since the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) uses clay to determine shoe quality, Adam and Jamie fill steel-toe boots with clay.
Then they dropped a 75-pound weight from 3 feet high. The weight mashed the leather and compressed the clay just 0.5 inches. The steel did not cut the shoes or curl.
They did the same experiment with traditional work shoes. The weight mashed the leather and splashed the clay.
Then they did the same test with 400 pounds weight. It damaged the steel, which showed that such impact could also damage the toe.
They finally dropped the same weight from 6 feet to see whether it cuts off the toes. The steel got smashed, but the toe-cutting myth was proven completely wrong.
It was concluded that an impact of 6000lbs can completely destroy the steel toe shoes and create severe damage to the toes. But a 1200lbs impact on normal shoes can cause the same damage to your toe.
So, do steel toe boots cut your toes off?
This test proves that steel toe shoes are safe to use. It is also proven that steel shoe boots do not cut off toes.
Do Your Steel Toe Boots Cause Any Foot Problems?
Steel boots are meant to protect your toes from impact. They focus more on protection and less on comfort. This leads to discomfort and some minor problems in your feet.
Less flexibility: Steel toe boots are not that flexible. You know what are steel toe boots designed for. It does not allow you to move your toe much inside the shoes.
You feel chafed, especially when you buy the wrong size shoes. It may cause pain when wearing them for a long time.
Sore: You may also experience soreness after removing the shoes off. Steel toes are made of heavy thick steel for maximum protection. You need to wear and carry those heavy shoes throughout the day. It causes sores.
Sweating: Steel toe boots might not be as breathable as other shoes. You may experience sweating in your toes when working in a hot condition for a long time.
Pain: You may also experience pain when wearing the wrong shoes. It is not possible to stretch your feet inside the steel toe. If the size is smaller, your toe will get squeezed. This can lead to blisters, calluses, corns, and other problems.
All these problems mainly occur due to improper size. The work intensity and working conditions also play a vital role in this discomfort and foot problems.
So, Should You Wear Steel-Toe Shoes?
Are steel toe boots designed to cut off toes?
No, they are meant to protect your toes. If you wear the right size shoes and pick the right one, you can enjoy wearing them with comfort. They will also deliver comfort and not cause pain at all.
You should wear steel-toe shoes if you want to protect your feet from high impact. And you must wear them if you work in a dangerous working condition such as a construction site. These simple shoes will make your working environment secure and safe.
Remember that not all steel toe shoes protect you from punctures or sharp objects. So be careful when dealing with them.
Tips To Get Rid of Foot Problems While Wearing Steel Toe Boots
You can make your steel toe boots more comfortable and wear them for a long time. Follow the steps below.
- Try to pick the best steel-toe shoes with higher insulation, perfect fitting, and enough comfort.
- Use padding when wearing steel-toe shoes.
- Try to avoid wearing them daily.
- Take off your shoes at a regular interval for better insulation.
- Do not wear them right after the day you buy them.
- Wear thick socks for more protection.
Top 3 Steel Toe Shoes for Toe Protection
Picking up the right steel toe shoes is not a cup of tea. Here are some suggestions for you.
1. Skechers Men’s Burgin-Tarlac Industrial Boot – for men
And Skechers for Work Women’s Workshire Peril Steel Toe Boot – for women
Skechers Men’s Burgin-Tarlac Industrial Boot is an excellent option for impact and electric safety. It features a steel toe with memory foam inside. You can enjoy superior comfort yet get high protection against impact.
It also offers electrical safety. If you work in such a condition where electrical shock might be a problem, this one can be a good option. 100% rubber construction reduces creasing and enhances comfort.
The rubber outsole delivers superior traction on the wet surface. You can enjoy wearing the shoes while walking and working with these shoes. Its lace-up facility ensures better fitting for even more comfort.
2. Caterpillar Men’s Revolver Pull-On Steel Toe Work Boot
These dark brown classic steel toe boots from Caterpillar Men’s Work Boot offer style and protection. The classic look will improve your personality in the workplace, where steel toe will ensure safety against impact or compression.
Its full leather design delivers higher longevity. The long shaft provides even more safety. Wearing and removing the shoes is child play due to its long Dual pull handles. You can comfortably wear it, and it will fit perfectly.
The slip-resistant rubber outsole provides maximum traction in wet or slippery conditions. You will also have nylon mesh lining for better breathability. It helps you stay cool and sweat-free in hot working conditions.
3. GW Men’s 1606ST Steel Toe Work Boots
You may need to work in wet and watery conditions sometimes. GW Men’s 1606ST Steel Toe Work Boots can be a perfect pair of toe work boots for such conditions. The steel toe design with pure leather construction offers maximum safety and longevity.
It also offers a slip-resistance rubber outsole for better traction in slippery conditions. You also have a premium water-resistance upper for even more water protection. The lace facility helps you wear and remove the shoes easily. It also makes the shoes fit perfectly for better comfort.
You can pick from different colors to match your personality and set yourself apart from others in the workplace. This pair of shoes is tough, durable, and comfortable to enjoy your work with full safety and protection.
How To Measure the Safety Standard for Steel Toe Shoes?
The American Society for Testing and Material set a safety standard for the shoes. You can understand the safety quality of the shoes if you know how to read the standard.
For example:
ASTM F2413-11
M I/75/C/75/Mt75
PR
You may find a label like that. The first part indicates that it was issued in ASTM in 2011. The second line tells us whether the shoes are for men or women. M indicates male, where F indicates female.
I/75 means the impact ability of the shoes. I/75 refers to an impact rating of 75 pounds.
C refers to compression resistance, meaning how much weight it can withstand. C/75 means it can withstand up to 2500 pounds, whereas C/50 means it can withstand up to 1750 pounds. The Mt indicates metatarsal.
Lastly, we have PR.
It indicates the protection the shoes offer against.
PR means puncture resistance. You can get protection against puncture. A puncture resistance plate is located in the middle of the outsole and insole for puncture protection.
CD stands for conductive. You can get protection against any static electrical hazard. EH refers to electrical hazards. These shoes protect the users from any electrical shock.
Before making a purchase, make sure you follow the safety standard measurements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you still have some questions in mind? Have a look at the section below.
How much weight can a steel toe boot withstand?
It depends on the quality of steel. A good pair of steel-toe shoes can easily withstand up to 2500 pounds of impact.
Are steel toe boots comfortable?
Steel toe boots are designed for protection, not for comfort. You might not get as comfortable as general sneakers. But you can get the job done comfortably.
Time To Say Bye
So, can steel toe shoes cut your toes off?
Not at all. Steel toe shoes are designed especially for toe protection. They offer superior safety against medium to high impact, falling, or puncture.
Yes, there was a case. But that was not because of the steel-toe shoes. The scenario would be worse if the pipes fell on general work shoes. Steel toe shoes have nothing to do with toe cut-off.
It is a complete myth, and many proofs are there now to debunk the myths. Many experiments have been done to prove that steel toe shoes do not cut off the toes. You can easily wear the shoes to ensure your safety in the workplace.